A letter announcing a higher private health insurance premium can raise difficult questions. Is the increase normal? Did you choose the wrong policy? Can you afford further increases? Should you change something now?
For expats in Germany, the uncertainty can be greater when the letter is in German and the original consultation focused on the starting price. Understanding the difference between a market headline, a tariff example and your personal contract is the first step towards a useful review.
This guide explains the cost pressures, published examples for Hallesche NK.select XL, SIGNAL IDUNA EXKLUSIV-SI and ARAG MedBest MB0, and how to prepare a conversation about your own cover. A premium increase alone does not establish that your policy was a poor choice. It does give you a reason to check the figures and your longer-term budget.
According to the German private health insurance association, PKV expenditure on medicines rose by around 8% in 2025. Spending on general hospital services increased by almost 7.5%. These are increases in expenditure, which can reflect prices, the amount of treatment and the treatments used. They are not simply medicine price inflation.
General inflation and medical cost pressures need to be distinguished. A lower headline inflation rate does not mean the level of healthcare costs has returned to where it was.
PKV premiums do not automatically rise a little each year. Adjustments depend on statutory and contractual triggers. Where those triggers have not been reached, costs can rise without an immediate premium adjustment. Once an adjustment is triggered, the resulting increase can feel sudden.
A stable premium for several years should therefore never be presented as a promise of permanent stability.
Hospital financing is also changing. A Bundestag legislative resolution provides for hospital surcharges from January 2027 of €27.30 per eligible inpatient or day-patient admission at non-university hospitals, and €50 at university hospitals during 2027. As of 16 November, the parliamentary process is not yet complete.
These proposed charges need context: the previous temporary 3.25% hospital invoice surcharge expired at the end of October 2026. The new arrangements are intended to replace part of that funding. It would be misleading to describe them simply as an additional charge on top of an unchanged system, or as the proven cause of a particular insurer’s premium increase.
Published specialist reports provide examples of adjustments from 1 January 2027. The distinction matters: the figures below concern new-business premiums, not a prediction of the increase in every existing contract.
For Hallesche, hc consulting reports the following examples for an adult aged 38:
| Hallesche tariff | Reported increase | Monthly increase |
|---|---|---|
| NK.select XL 600 | 15.4% | €113.70 |
| NK.select XL 1200 | 15.9% | €98.00 |
| NK.select XL 3000 | 17.2% | €76.90 |
| NK.select XL Bonus | 13.7% | €98.00 |
For SIGNAL IDUNA, KVoptimal reports these adult new-business figures:
| SIGNAL IDUNA tariff | Reported increase |
|---|---|
| EXKLUSIV-SI 0 | Approximately 8–9% |
| EXKLUSIV-SI 1 | Approximately 2% |
| EXKLUSIV-SI 2 | Approximately 10% |
For ARAG MedBest MB0, hc consulting reports new-business examples of approximately 12% at age 26, 11% at age 32, 10% at ages 38 and 44, and 9% at age 55. ARAG’s own overview gives an average range of 9–11% for the adult MedBest product line. That product-line summary is not a precise quotation for every MB0 policy. Existing policyholders should use their personal adjustment notice.
Even within one tariff family, the changes differ considerably. Your own adjustment letter is the relevant starting point for reviewing your contract. A percentage shared in a community group may concern a different variant, age or contribution basis.
Start with your documents rather than a percentage someone else received. Put the new notice next to your previous contribution breakdown and policy schedule. Review the same insured person, the same components and the same effective date.
Copy the complete tariff designation, including numbers and suffixes. “EXKLUSIV-SI” alone is not enough when variants 0, 1 and 2 have different reported adjustments. The same applies to the deductible and Bonus variants of NK.select XL.
Check which line items changed. Your total payment may include health insurance, compulsory long-term care insurance and additional components. An increase in one tariff component is not necessarily the percentage increase in the entire monthly payment.
Subtract the previous contribution from the new contribution. Then divide the difference by the previous contribution and multiply by 100. Use matching components on both sides of the calculation.
| Illustrative calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Previous monthly contribution | €650 |
| New monthly contribution | €715 |
| Monthly increase | €65 |
| Percentage increase | 10% |
| Additional cost over 12 months | €780 |
This is an invented example, not an insurer quotation. It compares the same contribution components and assumes the increase applies for a full year. It does not calculate your personal cost after any employer contribution or tax effects.
For an employee, the invoice increase and the change in personal out-of-pocket cost may differ. Ask payroll to confirm the employer contribution that applies to your circumstances. If you are self-employed, build the full contribution payable into your business and household planning.
Ask which components increased, what reasons the insurer gives, when the change takes effect and what options exist within your contract. If the letter refers to a deadline, have its meaning checked promptly rather than leaving it until the end of the month.
Community discussions can alert you to a change, but they rarely include enough detail for a meaningful comparison. A friend may have another tariff variant, different benefits, a different age or additional insured components.
Ask for a comparison of like with like. “My friend pays less” is a reason to investigate the details, not evidence that you can obtain equivalent cover at that price.
A quick comparison can make private health insurance look like a decision about today’s monthly price. But you are choosing protection that may need to fit your life for decades.
Before signing, you should have had the opportunity to discuss future premium increases, affordability in retirement, family plans, changes in income and a possible move abroad. You should also know who will help you when your circumstances or premiums change.
Good advice cannot prevent healthcare costs from increasing. It can help you prepare a realistic budget and understand the decision you are making.
Receiving an increase does not, by itself, prove that your original advice or policy was wrong. But if the possibility was never explained, or nobody is available to discuss the letter now, there is a conversation worth having.
If you feel unsettled, begin with the contract and the letter. Which components have changed? What is the euro increase? What does it mean for your household budget?
Then review your options with someone who can explain the consequences. An internal tariff change may be worth examining. Section 204 VVG provides rights to change tariffs within the insurer, subject to its conditions; additional benefits may involve risk assessment. Lower premiums should be assessed alongside benefits, deductibles and the protection you would give up.
Moving to another insurer is a separate decision that needs careful assessment. A cheaper starting quote alone does not establish that it is the better long-term choice.
Future increases remain a planning risk. Nobody can responsibly promise that your premium will never rise again.
A review should address more than how to make next month’s bill smaller. Talk through the situations that could change your ability to pay: parental leave, a period without employment, a lower household income, retirement or a move abroad.
For expats supporting relatives overseas, include those commitments in the budget. A premium that feels manageable while both partners are working may need a different planning approach if the household later relies on one income.
Use scenarios rather than promises. Ask what your budget would look like at a higher contribution and how much reserve you could maintain. A scenario is a planning exercise, not a forecast of what your insurer will charge.
No. An increase needs to be assessed alongside your benefits, the contribution history and your needs. Neither one year of stability nor one large adjustment is enough to judge the quality of a long-term contract.
Not necessarily. The tables describe published new-business examples and specified age groups. Your personal adjustment notice is the basis for reviewing your existing policy. Do not apply a new-business percentage to your current payment and treat the result as a quotation.
Compare the annual premium saving with the additional costs you could have to pay yourself. Also discuss any effect on employer contributions and your ability to reverse the decision later. A lower monthly debit can still leave you with a worse result over the year.
No. An internal change stays within the current insurance company and is governed by its applicable terms and tariff-change rights. Moving to another insurer involves a separate application and assessment. Ask for a written explanation of benefit differences and financial consequences before choosing either route.
Begin with a review. Do not cancel first and try to solve the replacement question afterwards. A new offer should be assessed for acceptance, coverage, cost and continuity before you make a binding decision.
No reliable advice can promise a future premium path. An alternative may have a lower contribution today, but that alone does not establish better long-term value or suitability.
Use the document-sharing method agreed with your adviser for personal information. You do not need to publish policy or medical details in a social media comment.
You do not have to make sense of a premium increase alone.
I have been advising clients on private health insurance since 1999. Together with Nina Feddersen, a private health insurance specialist since 2012, I advise expats on their cover and long-term planning. If your latest letter has left you unsure, we can take another look together.
We can review your cover, explain the changes and discuss whether the policy still fits your circumstances and long-term budget. Sometimes, keeping your current policy is the right decision. The point is to understand your options before deciding.
Explore private health insurance advice and request a personal consultation, or contact NEOdirect on WhatsApp through the website. We can discuss your questions in English.
Martin B. Grödl, known as Mr Martin, has advised clients on private health insurance since 1999. Nina Feddersen has specialised in private health insurance since 2012. Together, they advise expats at NEOdirect on choosing and reviewing cover in the context of their personal circumstances.